Shemar Stewart @ 17 ?

[*Synric*]

(03-28-2025, 10:37 AM)Truck_1_0_1_ Wrote: Production isn't end all, be all (just like athletic profile isn't either), but he had NO production, essentially.

IMO, that's alarming.


So I see he planted the LT on his ass a few times, good good.

Otherwise, he looks like Brandon Thompson to me (not in terms of position or physical look, obviously): beats his guy every time, but 49/50 times is not in the play.

I loved seeing Thompson's first step and him getting into the backfield all the time, but he was out of the play almost every time and the same in the clips of Stewart you showed: of those snaps, how many plays did he actually make or affect? 3 at best?

I'm not sold.

I'd much rather take Scourton (though not at 17. Not sure he drops to 49 either).

He collected 2 pressure and a run stop in that clip (stats) and affected 2 more run plays. That doesn't count almost getting to Nussmiers arm on that quick pass. Shemar Stewart is always in the backfield and it affects the plays/play calling. There's not alot of long developing plays against the Texas A&M defense. He needs to finish while he's in thr back field that is not in question but there isn't alot of Defensive Ends that can play both the run and pass every in this draft.


I have Shemar Stewart, Walter Nolen, Kenneth Grant, Mykel Williams, Nick Emmanwori all in the same bucket. High End athletes with raw inconsistent tape.