Rank Our QBs (2025)

[*rfaulk34*]

(05-01-2025, 09:59 PM)TheLeonardLeap Wrote: And lately Mahomes was 1 game away from having THREE STRAIGHT SUPERBOWL RINGS.


Burrow didn't have an MVP quality season because he couldn't get the Ws in the end. He was 9-8 overall and just 2-7 against teams with a winning record. He missed the playoffs because he couldn't even throw 200 yards or even 1 TD against the Patriots.

If Burrow elevates players around him more than anyone else, why did we need to overpay Tee to keep him paired with the highest paid WR in NFL history to make the highest paid WR duo in NFL history?

Mahomes had 5 4th Quarter Comebacks and 7 Game Winning Drives. He went 17-2 in 2025 and you're just focused on one game in one year for each player. Mahomes has never had less than double-digit wins, he has never missed the AFCC.



Mahomes career playoff 17 game average: 67.7% completion, 4,707 yards (7.7 YPA), 37 TD/8 INT, 105.4 QB Rating
Burrow career playoff 17 game average: 67.3% completion, 4,435 yards (7.3 YPA), 22 TD/10 INT, 93.8 QB Rating 

Statistically better in every category, and obviously MUCH better in wins and rings. There's nothing wrong with accepting that the guy who will probably go down as the 2nd best QB in NFL history is the best QB in the NFL right now. Burrow being 2-3 in the NFL right now is still incredibly good.

Plus, i already kinda showed the 5 times Burrow had the ball in his hands last year with a chance to win and didn't finish. I'm glad he's the QB of the Bengals because i believe he has the ability to win a championship. 


Ok. (start) rant. 

If you think Joe Burrow is the #1 best QB in the NFL right now, your opinion on players should never again be taken seriously. Ever. Mahomes is clearly the #1 QB in the NFL right now and the one and only QB i would trade Burrow for. To me, Burrow is #2 with Jackson and Allen in the conversation. I would not trade Burrow for any QB in the NFL today, other than Mahomes. Throw in all the excuses you want. I'll have an answer for every one of them. Mahomes just doesn't fail in crunch time with the game on the line. 
(end) rant.