04-17-2016, 12:18 AM
(04-16-2016, 10:12 PM)TheLeonardLeap Wrote: Year 1...
Gio: 170 carries/695 yards (4.1 YPC, 3 of 20+), 2 TD ... 56 catches/514 yards (9.2 AVG), 3 TD
Jamaal: 60 carries/357 yards (5.3 YPC, 3 of 20+), 0 TD ... 27 catches/272 yards (10.1 AVG), 1 TD
Year 2...
Gio: 168 carries/680 yards (4.0 YPC, 2 of 20+), 5 TD ... 43 catches/349 yards (8.1 AVG), 2 TD
Jamaal: 190 carries/1,120 yards (5.9 YPC, 9 of 20+), 7 TD ... 40 catches/297 yards (7.4 AVG), 1 TD
Year 3...
Gio: 157 carries/730 yards (4.7 YPC, 2 of 20+), 2 TD ... 49 catches/472 yards (9.6 AVG), 0 TD
Jamaal: 230 carries/1,467 yards (6.4 YPC, 10 of 20+), 5 TD ... 45 catches/468 yards (10.4 AVG), 3 TD ... Pro Bowl, 1st Team All-Pro
That looks like a lot of difference between Gio and Charles' first three years to me. Kind of silly to compare them. I really like Gio, but that's just goofy.
What is silly is that you get bent out of shape when I make a reasonable statement. As I stated outside of YPC which I stated Charles is clear edge... there is not a lot of difference between the two players after three seasons.
Total yards 3,981 for Charles to 3,440, Avg per year: Charles 1,327 to Gio 1,147, Carries Gio 495 to 480, Catches Gio 148 to 112 for Charles TDs- Charles 17 to Gio 14. So Charles has edge in yards, slight edge in TDs, and Gio has edge in receptions. This does not look like a landslide victory that you seemed to bent on outside of YPC which I gave him.
and I am going to make a bold prediction that after season 4, Gio will have more of every category except for YPC... would you like to take that bet ?? I am confident that Gio will stay much more healthy than Charles since Charles only played a couple games in season 4 but if Charles had just a great advantage after 3 years as you have so strongly defended how in the world could poor Gio over take him after 4 seasons even with a injury..