Finally getting some legitimate analysis of Kirkpatrick's play in '15

[*bfine32*]

(08-05-2016, 07:59 PM)fredtoast Wrote: Dre has 13 penalties and 4 of them did not involve coverage (taunting, facemask, illegal block above the waist, unnecessary roughness)

BTW 5 of the top 8 CBs in penalties were Pro Bowl players and two were All-Pro

2nd Aquib Talib....Pro Bowl last 3 straight years
5th Richard Sherman...First Team All Pro 3 times.  Pro Bowl last 4 straight years.
5th Marcus Peters....Pro Bowl this year.
7th Josh Norman.... First Team All Pro this year
7th Vontae Davis... Pro Bowl last two years

So by Fred Logic Penalties are a good thing. I think you tried this before and we found it just as amusing then. 

Here's the deal:

Dre Kirkpatrick is average in pass coverage
Dre Kirkpatrick is poor in run support
Dre Kirkpatrick in the worst in the league at creating turnovers
Dre Kirkpatrick is the worst CB in the NFL in penalties committed
PFF rates him as the 3rd worst CB in the NFL (of those that qualified)

Yet somehow this leaves Fred Toast to assert he is a top 20 (amended to top 32 once even he saw how silly that was) in the NFL. 

I put him currently as mediocre (of ordinary quality; neither bad or good). 

One of us is right, the other is just trying real hard.  We'll let folks decide.