Dalton or Luck?

[*rfaulk34*]

(10-01-2016, 12:57 AM)Brownshoe Wrote: Luck has a horrible record outside of his division. I think it's under .500 since 2013 tbh.


EDIT: Luck is 10-17 in games he's started against people outside of his division since 2013.

Oh, i know. I've pointed that out many times. If you ask pretty much anyone, they will tell you that top to bottom, the Bengals have a much better roster than the Colts. A better coaching staff and system too. 

At this point, i wouldn't trade them straight up if offered, but just speaking hypothetically, in the exact same circumstances, i think Luck could do a little bit more. Most of it would have come in the early years though. It took Dalton a while to get where he is, whereas Luck came in able to put up bigger numbers.