Dalton or Luck?

[Brownshoe]

(10-01-2016, 09:55 PM)Essex Johnson Wrote: ok so now it is the first three years instead of right away.. i see you shifting things... as for more with less .. I don;t agree at all with that statement, both teams were building for the future with young and older players... They still had Wayne and a veteran in Avery at WR so they still had a edge even with Green coming in, and their offensive line was on par with ours, we had a edge at Running back, so really splitting hairs on who was deeper.

You just seem to be holding on to this idea that Luck was so superior to Dalton starting out with a much more minor league team and I don;t think the stats or personal support that.. THE END

Since Rfaulk likes passer rating a lot... Dalton had a better passer rating both his first and second years vs Lucks first 2nd second years...

Passer rating by years
Year 1: Dalton > Luck
Year 2: Dalton > Luck
Year 3: Luck > Dalton
Year 4: Dalton > Luck
Year 5: Most likely Dalton > Luck

Yep... Luck is better