07-13-2015, 11:09 AM
(07-13-2015, 11:01 AM)RoyleRedlegs Wrote: I actually think Andy compares pretty well to Eli in terms of (regular season) career trajectory
I do too, but I think the fact that Eli came back with a solid 2014 after his miserable 2013 puts him back ahead of Andy in most rankings. His SB runs were at least a few years ago now, so I'm not even sure we could say that Eli is clearly better today because of those.
Not to mention he wasn't really swamped with talent in 2014 either, he had Beckham to throw jump balls to and that's about it. Not a good line, receivers dropped more passes than Andy's, not many weapons in general, pretty miserable run game, and a pretty bad defense to boot. I give a lot of credit to Eli for rebounding and looking like a good QB last season, I can honestly say I didn't think he had it in him after watching him throughout 2013.
