I feel bad for Andy

[Shake n Blake]

(12-26-2016, 05:00 PM)bfine32 Wrote: Ones most would agree on:

Ben - yes
Drew - yes
Tom - yes
Aaron - yes
Russell - probably, but close (Wilson has had a much better sitch)
Cam - About the same. Dalton is a better passer. Btw, have you watched him this year?
Romo - a few years ago yeah, not sure anymore 
Ryan - Similar level
Luck - Similar level, although Dalton has been more efficient through their careers 
Stafford - He's pretty much the NFC version of Dalton


Younger QBs making a case:
Winston - Not quite yet
Matrrota - No, but it's still early in his career
Carr - Maybe, but I think the kid is a tad overhyped
Prescott - Way too early to call + look at the team around him
Tannehill - Lol

Vets that could compare:
Eli - Agreed
Rivers - Agreed since Rivers has fallen a notch
CP9 - Not anymore, Palmer is falling off

So giving and taking benefit of the doubt; I'd put Andy 13-17 (middle of the pack)

Now list starting QBs that you think are clearly worse than Andy.

I'll give you Tom, Brees, Ben, Rodgers, Wilson, Ryan and Carr for sure. Anyone else, you can at least make a solid stats backed case that Dalton is as good or better as of now. I have Dalton right around 10th give or take a couple spots.

Like Fred said though...can't you give a definitive list? It shouldn't be difficult if you really think Dalton is mediocre.