Final Regular Season QB rankings

[*bfine32*]

(01-13-2017, 08:57 AM)Wyche Wrote: Well.....y'all rated Philly Rivers ahead of him....21 picks AND a worse record.  Now what?

I say Andy is in the 8-13 range and that ain't bad....but ffs man....people said he needed to cut down on INTs....he does that....and now he needs to throw more picks.  The goalposts never stop moving for this guy.

Lets go with the high of 8; as I've seen folks (around here) suggest it.

I think we all (ok, most) can agree that the following have proven to be better during Andy's time in the league:

Brady
Rodgers
Ben
Matt
Brees
Wilson
Rivers

To put him at 8 you would have to say he's ahead of:
Luck
Newton
Smith
Palmer
Flacco
Romo
Cousins
Stafford
Prescott
Mariota
Winston
Tannehill


Now ask yourself this question:

Who has the better argument, the guy that puts him a 8 or the one that puts him at 17. 

Here's the thing: I've never asked for Andy to be replaced; as I know we can win with him; but for those that put him in top tier; why do you call for the HC to be replaced? Do you not think he could be successful elsewhere?