02-01-2017, 10:00 PM
(01-27-2017, 03:25 PM)rfaulk3 Wrote: In 2005 Carson was better than Ben. FULL STOP.
Overall, no.
That's why when someone says "in 2005..." you can't come back with "time has proven us Steelers fans right." On another good team, Carson could have been a HOFer.
Well, I agree Carson was better in 2005. Classic passer.
But I have to say, Ben did very well as a rookie. Once he stepped in for Maddox, every Steeler fan could see he gave us a better chance to win. He was, indeed, clutch. And he only got better.