05-18-2015, 11:09 AM
(05-18-2015, 01:41 AM)Brownshoe Wrote: 40-21-1 and 33 tds 4300 yards that should give you some confidence. You should watch some other QBs in the league. Dalton can get us where we want to go.
0-4, 53 INT over the last 3 years, and the fact that he can't even hit a miserable 70 passer rating in the playoffs should give you some skepticism.
Look, I'm on record saying that I believe in Andy and I think he can prove a lot of us wrong in 2015, but I'm not going to pretend that there aren't plenty of things to be worried about with him. I know that you're much higher on Andy than most, but you should at least understand why everybody else in the world doesn't share your point of view.
There aren't heated debates over whether Aaron Rodgers is a good QB or not. There aren't heated debates over whether Brandon Weeden is a good QB or not. The reason JN has always been so crazy over Andy is because he isn't a slam dunk good or bad QB. There are plenty of attributes that show both sides, and I don't think either extreme side is correct when they say that Andy absolutely CAN get us there, or that Andy absolutely CAN'T get us there.
