If you could add any former Bengal whose career was ruined by injury...

[*TheLeonardLeap*]

If we're allowing non-injuries to be on the list, then most certainly Odell Thurman. 98 tackle, 1.5 sack, 5 INT, 4 FF... and that was just his rookie season. Can you imagine if the Bengals had that kind of LB anchoring the middle of their defense for 10-15 years?

Imagine Mike Zimmer's defenses, but replace Rey Maualuga with Odell Thurman.

- - - - - - -

If we're talking pure injury, then probably Pollack, with an open-ended reservation to change it to Eifert if he never stays healthy.