04-17-2017, 01:46 AM
(04-16-2017, 08:40 AM)SHRacerX Wrote: That title may mislead folks, and that was not my intention, but I was trying to understand why the trade had not happened at this point. The answer I came up with was: Why should it?
I mean, why make the trade today without knowing of the value of pick #33 for the Bengals? Also, why would the Jets or someone (Texans?) offer a pick without knowing what QB they will have a shot at in the 2nd round or if they can trade back in the first to get a Kizer or Mahonnes.
What I am hoping for (for more reasons than just an AJM trade) is that there is a run on QBs in Rd 1. No one saw Ponder, Gabbert, and Locker going as early as they did in Dalton's draft class. Teams will talk themselves in to a QB. Then, if the Browns are left without a QB. Say, SF surprises and takes Trubisky, and the Browns wait and another team takes Watson, that #33 pick might be offered for AJM.
My hope would be a player that can compete at LT, but could also be a very good prospect at Guard, would be there target at #33. The only two players I can think of that fit that prospect are Forrest Lamp and Cam Robinson. Most see Lamp as a guard anyways, but he has a lot of LT experience and he actually held up very well against Alabama's defensive talent.
The more I think about it, the more I believe the Bengals are better off waiting with AJM until draft day and see what happens elsewhere. His value could actually go up.
It also comes down to value as well. People tend to over-hype McCarron around here, but you have to think about it this way.
If you're the Browns, would you rather draft Mahomes, Tribusky, Watson, Webb, Kizer; or trade a pick for AJ McCarron who has one year left?
Same with the other QB needy teams, which actually aren't as many as people believe.
Browns need a QB, 49ers need a QB, Texans need a QB, Jets may need a QB (no idea what they want to do), Chargers and Cardinals need a QB for the future. Sure, there's other wildcards, but there's no real desperation at QB this year.
Plus, if you miss out on a QB, you still have players like Cutler and Kaepernick who are free agents.
I honestly don't see McCarron going anywhere this year. I'd like to trade him, but I honestly don't think it'll happen.