Bengals brilliant in taking Kicker Elliot over Gonzalez

[McC]

(05-14-2017, 12:48 AM)Steve Wrote: so I guess if we had the #1 pick in the last draft...& instead of picking the #1 rated guy, DE Garrett we instead pick the 24th ranked player DE Taco Charlton.....you'd be ok w/ that...???   & just say, well who knows ....rankings mean nothing....

YOU PLAY TO WIN THE GAME..!!!

Stupid and failed analogy.  We get it.  You did that brilliant thing where you decide ahead of time.  You know more than one of the best ST coaches in the game.  There have been great small kickers and great bigger kickers.  That argument holds no weight at all.

Only time will tell who's right.  If you're right, of course you will devote pages to telling us all you told us so.  If you're wrong, will you devote even one sentence to admitting it?  The answer to that, like the answer to who is the better kicker, remains to be seen.

Was Joe Montana the highest rated QB in his draft?  Was Tom Brady?