07-02-2017, 04:20 PM
(07-01-2017, 03:17 PM)bfine32 Wrote: FWIW, These are the QBs I'd rather go into 2018 with than Andy:
Tom Brady
Andy Luck
Marcus Mariota
Ben Rothliesberger
Philip Rivers
Alex Smith
David Carr
Dak Prescot
Kirk Cousins
Matt Ryan
Jameis Winston
Drew Brees
Cam Newton
Matt Stafford
Aaron Rodgers
Russell Wilson
So I guess I have Andy rated around 17th. As I mentioned before he's not the problem on this team (at least in Regular season), but I'm not going to put him anywhere around 11th best in the NFL.
I could only agree with 7 of your names. I also wanted to cross over Derek Carr until he balled out for another season or 2. I think anybody whose been doing it 2 years or less is automatically out. I almost take it as disrespect to rank Dak and Winston ahead of Andy right now. Couple other names are sexy names but Dalton statistically has been as good or BETTER than them for the duration of their careers. Like Cam, and Alex Smith.
Based off my ideas Dalton is easily top 10. Give Andy Dak's o line and hell be just as good or even better at throwing the ball. Also remember Dalton is very sneaky at running in first downs and TDs. Hes not a runner but is consistently one of the most effective scoring QBs on the ground.
My fave feature of Andy's is he never complains or throws anyone under the bus. He plays hard and takes it all in stride. When guys are hurt he plays with the same passion as he does during the 2 games all season where everyone is healthy lol
Im glad hes our QB
