According to yahoo, Bengals tied with Giants for 18th best QB options in the NFL

[*bengalfan74*]

(07-04-2017, 04:15 PM)bfine32 Wrote: 4. Only been defending Marvin from the experts on here that blame him for everything. So you disagree with the coach's ranking and feel Marvin should be ahead of Adam Gase and Dan Quinn; fair enough. I think they have shown enough promise to currently get the nod over Marvin.

6. How could AJ be dead last with 68.3 while Andy boasts a 57.8. True there have been 4 QBs that have played under Marvin any idea who the worst is? Let's look at the games and see if we can find a reason:

Pitt 05: Carson was getting ready to blow up Pittsburgh anyone who questions that is either fooling themselves or being disingenuous. Kitna comes in cold and throws as many playoff TDs as Andy has in his Career,

NYJ 09:  Game was on a field that was a sheet of ice

11-14: 3 games played indoors and one game played in perfect outdoor conditions. QB combines for a passer rating of 57.8

Pitt 15: Played in the rain and Starting his 3rd ever NFL game AJ McCarron has a passer rating that is 10 points higher than the combined playoff rating of the Bengal QB that had started the previous 4'

Of course if one wanted to go with the "It's the coach" slant then one would expect both Palmer and Kitna to do better in their playoff games under different coaches. Do you need me to share those numbers with you

One game by a QB under any HC proves nothing ! It's the body of work that equals up to the sum.

But in your opinion, how many more seasons does Marvin need to get a fair chance ? What would you tell the experts on here ?

Does 0-8 in the playoffs do it ? 0-10 ? If he goes 3 more seasons against Pittsburgh and still hasn't got this third win at PBS against them does that do it ?

You tell us at what point Marvin can be held accountable.