Good Andy/Bad Andy

[Shake n Blake]

(10-07-2017, 09:28 AM)CornerBlitz Wrote: This proves a few things.

1. Dalton is highly inconsistent
2. There are other QBs in the NFL that are also inconsistent.

Guys like Carson and Newton are some of the most inconsistent players in league history along with Dalton. With guys like Carson and Newton, you don't know what you will get year to year. With Dalton, you don't know what you'll get game to game.

Let's also look at the players you decided to choose and realize what they've accomplished in their career.

Big ben has won two Super Bowls.
Flacco has won a super bowl and was the SB MVP.
Newton has made it to the super bowl and the conference championship. He's also been league MVP.


Andy Dalton has done absolute nothing note worthy in terms of team success other than a few decent regular season records. Perhaps if Dalton had actually done something in the playoffs we'd be a little bit more forgiving but the fact remains that not only is he inconsistent, but he hasn't gotten us close to what we truly want; heck you could make the case it was AJM that came closer.

1. If you consider Dalton to be highly inconsistent based on these numbers, then you must think that most NFL QBs are highly inconsistent.

2. I explained why I decided to choose the QBs I listed, and Ben, Luck, Newton, Carson and Flacco are some of the better QBs in the NFL. I also offered to list the numbers for any QB you want me to look up. So if you're not happy with the list, shoot me some names.

3. I knew when I made this thread that people would try to deflect and start talking about accomplishments somehow making it "ok" for other QBs to be inconsistent, yada yada. This thread is about Andy Dalton supposedly being more inconsistent than other QBs. That's it, period. He either is or he isn't.