Who is more valuable in the open market, AJM or Dalton?

[muskiesfan]

I'm not sure why I bothered voting because this is absolutely ridiculous. No way McCarron would bring in more than Dalton. We're comparing apples to oranges at best and it's not even close. Why does anyone think that an unproven, career back-up is going to bring in more than a proven starter?

Who would bring a bigger return in a trade, Joey Votto or Gavin LaValley? That question is on par with this one.