08-19-2015, 10:27 PM
(08-19-2015, 05:50 PM)GarbageDisposal Wrote: This thread speaks to a tendency to overrate our own players because we know them, because they're "ours," whereas if they were on another team they wouldn't be notable or getting such high marks. Let me explain. Zeitler and Iloka are really the only two "gems" in that. Kirkpatrick isn't a bust yet, but he's actually been pretty below average overall and hasn't lived up to his first round status yet.
I wouldn't criticize fans around here as much for acting like we can't judge Dre until his 4th season when there is a thread on the very board laughing about a guy the Steelers have had for a few months having a hard time adjusting to the NFL.