02-28-2018, 04:23 PM
(02-28-2018, 03:11 PM)shanebo Wrote: I don't support this proposed rule change in the least, as I think it will result in a lot more intentional pass interference by DBs -- anytime a DB is beat by 15 yards or more, ball is in the air, he can tackle the WR pre-catch and it's a win. More thuggery than skill. You already see this to a certain extent in college and in the end zone in the NFL, followed by the obligatory color commentator remark "good defensive play, better than a huge gain/touchdown." Meanwhile I'm fuming b/c my team's WR just got destroyed by a dirty DB ... IMO the only reason this rule works in college is because college WRs are generally more open than NFL WRs -- often the DBs can't get to them to trip/tackle them before the ball gets there. That said, I doubt this rule passes because it runs contrary to the focus on offense and scoring in today's NFL.
Re No. 2 - I think Belicheck and the better coaches/coordinators will tell their DBs to interfere whenever they feel they're beat long. I'm guessing we'll see the Pats, Steelers, Eagles, and Vikings doing this from the outset, virtually eliminating long TDs against them. Merv won't get it for at least 2-3 years, though.
I either disagree with what you are saying or confused to what you are saying? It's still 15 yds either way under the new proposal if I grab the WR at 10 yds or 40 yds. Not sure how that is win? I see it the other way. How many times has a game been decided by a ticky tack PI on a long ball that wasn't even going to be close to completed and the offense gets the ball inside the 10?
