03-16-2018, 02:04 PM
(03-16-2018, 12:47 PM)fredtoast Wrote: Dalton drove us 52 yards in that situation. If the defense had given him the ball on the other teams 45 yard line like they did with Mccarron he may very well have scored a td.
Plus in '12 Dalton was facing the #7 defense in the league while Mccarron was working against the #21 defense.
And the #2 wr on the '12 Bengals was Andrew Hawkins and the TE was Jermain Gesham , while the #2 wr on the '15 team was Marvin Jones and the TE was Tyler Eifert.
But, yeah, McCarron completing one pass proves he was a much more clutch QB than Andy Dalton. Any idea why Mr. Clutch was never able to beat a team that won more than 5 games in '15 while Dalton beat three playoff teams?
I did not state that Mc is better than Dalton.
I did not state that Mc is more clutch than Dalton.
I did state that Mc made a key play at a key moment in a playoff game.
I did state that I am happy that he will get a chance to show if he can do that with any sort of consistency.
I don’t understand the need to discount the fact that he made a play, by running into this thread with your ifs and buts blazing, and your Andy Dalton flag flapping in the breeze.
I don’t see any sense in comparing the stats of guy who has started for 7 seasons with a guy who has less than a half season of starts under his belt. There is not much to compare.
Mc made a play. Is that such a bad thing?
