AD better deep ball than u think

[fredtoast]

(04-17-2018, 06:07 PM)wolverine515151 Wrote: Like I have said a million times and won't keep saying it because it is a waste of time, the qb rating is very inaccurate for deep balls. It allows a qb to go 3 for 16 with 2 td's like Dalton did and still score high with a 106 rating.

The only way I will conceed that point is if yoiu point to a better forumla.

But it has to be based on objective stats only.  None of this "open window" and "adjusting receiver" subjective stuff that has too much grey area.  

Here are some stats that you have already requested.

(04-11-2018, 08:27 PM)Shake n Blake Wrote: 2. No, most QB's do not have a high rating on 31+ yard throws. You're making this up. Tom Brady has a 67.0 rating on these throws since 2011. I showed you that. Ben has an 87.0 rating. Both are well behind Dalton's 101.7. 

3. I did show the completion percentages. Here they are again (since 2011) and I'll even throw in a few more QB's:

Aaron Rodgers- 39.5%
Andy Dalton- 34.8%
Pig Ben: 27.2%
Flacco: 25.7%
Newton: 24.9%
Brady: 22.5%

Now passer ratings:

Rodgers: 112.7
Dalton: 101.7
Newton: 95.2
Pig Ben: 87.0
Flacco: 86.0
Brady: 67.0

Complete stats:

Dalton: 55-158-2599-20-8 (101.7) 34.8%

Brady: 32-142-1542-9-9 (67.0) 22.5%
Ben: 58-213-2793-25-16 (87.0) 27.2%
Cam: 47-189-2012-21-6 (95.2) 24.9%
Rodgers: 47-119-2242-23-4 (112.7) 39.5%
Flacco: 49-191-2242-17-9 (86.0) 25.7%

So either put up another objective formula that you think accurately rates QBs throwing over 30 yards past the line of scrimmage, or stop whining about the formula used by the NFL to determin the top ranked passer.