AD better deep ball than u think

[fredtoast]

(04-26-2018, 12:09 AM)wolverine515151 Wrote: If it is subjective it isn't as blatant as you are making it look. Each throw is judged by how open a receiver is.  This is broken into several categories  of how open they are such as, wide open, very open open, open, slightly open,  blanketed. 

It isn't like the guy is judging whether a player is open or not hes merely judging where he fits into these categories. The only subjectivity would be to determine the difference between say slightly open to blanketed, not as blatantly subjective like whether he is open or not open. It is much more fine tuned than that primitive approach you are suggesting.

This is VERY subjective because you can not tell me what the difference is between "wide open" and "very open".  And what possible difference could it make to the QBs throw if a receiver is "wide open" or "very open"?  Wouldn't he make the exact same throw no matter how well the receiver is covered?

(04-26-2018, 12:09 AM)wolverine515151 Wrote: It isn't as subjective as the qb rating, which allows a qb to complete only 18% of his throws and score over a 100 rating. That is much more flawed and no way can you say a 18% completion percentage is a very effective qb on deep throws just because he throws a couple td's. 

Again you are just complaining about the formula without offering a better one that relies on objective stats.