05-19-2018, 07:14 PM
(05-19-2018, 02:44 AM)Shepdawg Wrote: If you could somehow go back in time and "resurrect" one former Bengals career that was a "bust" for whatever reason, injury included, which Bengal would it be? You get to exchange that players actual career with one that could be considered borderline HOF, maybe not a first ballot shoe in, but certainly in the discussion. In other words much closer to the career you thought they would have had.
Greg Cook was not a bust, just an injury that today would not have ended his career. Bill Walsh said he would have been the best QB in NFL history.
I voted for Akili Smith because the do-over would be to take the Saint's trade offer and get all those picks.