Tier 3 QB

[*bengalfan74*]

(07-29-2018, 12:43 AM)bfine32 Wrote: Actually it wasn't me it was 50 experts in the game. I think Andy ranked a little low in this poll, but I do not dismiss the young QBs just because they are young.

Who's a better RB:
Leonard Fornette or Lamar Miller

Who's a better CB:
Jalen Ramsey or Jimmy Smith

Who's a better DE:
Joey Bosa or Olivier Vernon

All the experienced players I listed have proven to be every bit as good at their position as Andy is at his. Of course it's subjective; unfortunately, it's not always objective.  



 

Befine I get what you're saying and agree with a lot, however, It's not dismissing a QB because he's young. That's a bit of a twist of the argument on your part.

I don't think anybody who watches football "dismisses" Jimmy G's potential, but at this point it's still just potential. You can't rank a QB young, old, in the middle, tall, fat, short, or whatever else in 13th place over proven with years of experience vets.

Now if he had a couple seasons under his belt it would be different. 7 games doe not make a rank of 13 in my book.

If you had a rookie LF in baseball who was a career 15-20 HR hitter with only average RBI's and he hit a HR in his first Major League at bat would you move your veteran producing hitter out of clean up and put him in ?