09-10-2018, 11:42 PM
(09-10-2018, 11:11 PM)Shake n Blake Wrote: I still find it interesting that AJ's fumble rate is nearly twice as high. I just think some people saying AJ is "miles" better is flat out insulting and forgetful. If you compare Chad's 5-6 best years to AJ's, Chad definitely has the better numbers, although AJ will probably get him on longevity.
On the field there are several things Chad did better, and at this point I think it'll stay that way. I have those 2 about even tbh.
You can go back and forth on both of them.. Chad was never a great route runner... AJ is better, Chad was athletic and great in the middle of the field... but from my eyes AJ is more dependable overall. Stats over the start of their career are very similar, Chad's skills did decrease once he got to 10th season. My personal opinion is i believe AJ is a harder worker to keep his craft at elite level than Chad was and that in the end will separate the two players and that is usually what can separate those that end up in the Hall of Fame and those that wear the jacket hoping to be in the Hall of Fame...