09-14-2015, 12:02 PM
(09-14-2015, 11:49 AM)Luvnit2 Wrote: We may all have different definition or standard for the word "elite".
In my mind, elite means HOF caliber. It does not mean potential to be a HOF WR or QB or whatever.
Calvin Johnson - yes, he has the stats
A. Brown - yes he is both a great WR (stats-results) and a great special teams player
Dez - Not yet, but close
A.J. Not yet, but close
Julio - Not yet
Jordy - Not as close as the others
DT - not in my mind
So, I have 2 guys elite, but others may say all of them are elite which is their opinion. I may not agree nor others agree with me, but that is my opinion.
But, they are all very good WR's no doubt.
You basically just argued with yourself with this post.
If AB goes down at the next Steelers practice with a career ending injury, he would NOT be a lock for the Hall of Fame. Therefore you shouldn't be able to consider him "elite" with your criteria.
