09-29-2015, 01:57 PM
(09-29-2015, 11:46 AM)ItsOdellThurman Wrote: We can concede that Tom Brady, Aaron Rodgers, Peyton Manning, Russell Wilson, Andrew Luck, Tony Romo, Drew Brees, Ben Roethlisberger, Cam Newton, Phillip Rivers and Matt Ryan are better than Andy Dalton. However, compare him to every other QB in the league and he not only compares favorably, but better. Others there's not enough sample size to bring into the argument or he's clearly better than. With that said...here you go.
Dalton (5 years) - 107 TD, 67 INT, 61.8 Comp %, 86.7 QBR
Stafford (7 years) - 136 TD, 90 INT, 59.8 Comp %, 83.4 QBR
Cutler (10 years) - 185 TD, 132 INT, 61.7 Comp %, 85.1 QBR
Flacco (8 years) - 152 TD, 94 INT, 60.7 Comp %, 84.7 QBR
Smith (10 years) - 126 TD, 79 INT, 60.5 Comp %, 83.0 QBR
Bradford (6 years) - 62 TD, 42 INT, 58.9 Comp %, 78.9 QBR
Palmer (12 years) - 233 TD, 157 INT, 62.6 Comp %, 86.9 QBR
Manning (12 years) - 263 TD, 185 INT, 59.1 Comp %, 82.7 QBR
Andy ranked 1st or 2nd in every stat, which includes TD/INT ratio, Comp % and QBR.
He's in a unique scenario where it's literally only the playoffs.
So what you're saying is he's pretty much in the middle of QBs right now since you lopped off 11 of them off the bat. Or in other words, what almost everyone else has already said time and time again.
