Stupid Rule

[Fresno B]

(09-29-2015, 11:12 AM)Daddy-O Wrote: So your response has gone from the rule is perfect to the rule needs to be possession through the whistle.  So which is it?  You can't say the rule is perfect and then also say it needs to be possession through the whistle.  

So in your opinion the rule needs to be changed to possession through the whistle, which obviously indicates the rule is not perfect? 

I think in a round about way you agree with my original post that it's a Stupid Rule! 

Far from perfect but eliminates mind states like yours which is it shoulda, coulda, woulda. We don't need 2 step football move crap if we change it to possession thru whistle. All you are advocating for is wanting to interpret what and what isn't a catch at the discretion of a referee, which is why were in this mess to begin with.