09-29-2015, 06:36 PM
(09-29-2015, 01:47 PM)djs7685 Wrote: Who is "they"? Where are people saying that? I'm guessing you're just making stuff up like people have for the last 4 years on Bengals boards. I've heard that you can't really judge a QB until his 2nd season, then his 3rd season, then his 4th season....now it's "after 4 years to 6 years"??? Interesting how "they" always seem to say this with no links or proof to back it up.
Yes, if you look up the QBs listed you will find bad games in all of them, Andy included, hence the reason I said that his issues weren't solely the playoffs. He wouldn't have a 85 rating from years 1 - 4 if his only issues were in the playoffs, that's all I said. I never said the other guys didn't have bad games either, they clearly have had their problems as well.
They are those that have played the game.. was listening to NFL network and it was mentioned that a true measure of a QB is at least 4 years in for them as a whole. I also heard Kenny Anderson mention that and how today rookie QB's are tossed in right away and you really need to wait a few years to get a real measure of them...
As for you mentioning Andy and bad games.. I don;t believe you added that other QB's also have bad games... come back to me with some real quotes and stats.. right now you just a sad shell of a poster :)
