07-16-2019, 11:46 PM
(07-16-2019, 07:21 PM)Synric Wrote: There are dozens of variables on a single play that they grade which they explained.
Actually they did not explain any of that.
Dalton hits a WR on the hands 10 yards downfield. Is that a 0, a +1, or a +2? Since he can't do it any better then that has to be a +2, right? But on the other hand that seems like a pretty common play. So then should it be a 0?
And isn't a 15 yard pass harder than a 10 yard pass? And a 20 yard pass harder than a 15 yard pass? and a 25 yard pass harder than a 20? And so on and so on and so on? So how do you tell the difference with just 3 options of "0", "+1", and "+2"
I read the article and it is clearly just subjective. There are no clear guidelines. Just whatever the grader feels is appropriate.
