10-01-2015, 10:40 AM
(09-30-2015, 06:29 PM)djs7685 Wrote: Marvin CAN beat Bill, but it has absolutely nothing to do with 2013. The statement that Marvin can beat Bill is absolutely the truth, but not for the reason that you and Fred are claiming.
You are starting to get nit, bit I don't think you realize it.
There are two different arguments here, and you are trying to mash them into one. You are taking my comments out of context to create a contradiction that does not exist.
The statement that it is impossible for Marvin to beat Belichick is disproven by the fact that Marvin has already beaten Belichick. That is a logical "proof". if you want to disagree with this argument then lets have that conversation. I want to here your argument that it is still impossible for Marvin to beat Belichick even though it has already happened.
The second argument is that the past dictates the future. If you want to argue that the past DOES dictate the future then I will also gladly have that discussion with you.
But it is impossible for you to agree with BOTH of my statements and then say there is a contradiction. You can't the argument used to disprove one simple claim and then try and apply it to a totally different claim.
And you can't claim a contradiction when you agree with BOTH comments.
