"Improvement" vs. "fixing everything"

[jfkbengals]

(09-22-2019, 12:11 PM)Luvnit2 Wrote: I judge improvement 1 way and that is wins versus losses versus 2018, the rest is all smoke in mirrors and mean nothing. If he wins 7 or more games he improved the team, if 6 or less he failed. I am not say fire him, but the roster was not blown up to rebuild so he should be able to do as well or better in wins as ML did.

But that doesn't really paint the picture.

Look at 2018.  With AJ and Andy in the lineup during the first half of the year, we were 5-3.  Without 1 or both in the second half of the season we were 1-7.

So suppose AJ never takes the field this season and we win 6 games, did Taylor fail as a HC?