Burrow, Tua, or Herbert?

[*rfaulk34*]

(11-19-2019, 11:41 AM)coachmcneil71 Wrote: All three qbs mentioned are talented guys with upside. Ts, they all also have certain drawbacks. I really don't have the time or patience to break this all down for folks, so I will make it very short. Tua- injury. Herbert- below average competition.

Burrow- I like Joe, he's an Ohio guy, but I dont want him or any of the QBs mentioned at #1!!! Now here I will try to explain to you thick heads why he may not be the "savior" that most of you seem to think he is. First and foremost is the system that he's playing in. The same system that Urbs Florida ran and dominated the SEC with during his time. Boy, that Tebow sure looked good....in that system! Auburn has remained relevant n the SEC by running the same type of system and they have had some luck. Auburn's man problem is their knack for not being able to find a QB that can get them there. Joe's lack of arm stregnth is going to be a problem at the next level. He's no Pat Mahomes!! Next, is our putrid offensive line. They will get him killed here.

Just to clarify; I like all three of the guys mentioned, but not at #1.

There are several very good pro style QBs n this draft besides the three that everyone keeps mentioning.

The Bengals have a chance to get the next Charles Haley and a starting QB in the first and second Rd of this draft. This is a no brainer!! If they do screw this up, as usual, I WILL be moving on after 40 plus years of everything Bengal.

You're falling into the same "system" argument that's flawed. 

Don't get me wrong, i'm not saying it's not a thing. What i'm saying is...forget about the system. Forget about past QBs. People need to get away from this thinking and start watching what a QB does, not where he is. 

Watch his performance late in games. 
Watch his completion percentage late in games. 
Watch his decision making late in games. 
Watch his performance and comp% when under pressure (and even moreso, under pressure...late in games).
Watch how he plays against tougher opponents. 
Watch where he's throwing the ball; open receivers or tight coverage. 
Watch his comp% on the move.
Watch how he moves to avoid pressure and if he panics and runs right out of the pocket at the first sign of pressure. 

There are so many things to watch with a QB that it's lazy and old school to just look at where they play and under what system.