Veteran Andy > Rookie Joe Burrow

[Shake n Blake]

(01-06-2020, 12:59 AM)bfine32 Wrote: Andy Dalton career passer rating: 87.5

Andy Dalton 2019 passer rating: 78.5 (-9.8)

Andy Dalton 2015 passer rating 106.3 (+18.8)

Yeah, they're both probably equally outliers. 

I'm saying he's the 32nd best QB because I can name 31 (or more) others I take over him. His rating just supports that.

You're not really helping your case by showing that his 2019 season rating was nearly 10 points below his career rating. This isn't a debate over which season was a bigger anomaly. The basic point here is that 2019 was an anomaly. Would it kill you to admit that?

To your last line, there's nothing to debate because that's your opinion. I think Dalton is better than the guys I listed, some of which were barely above Dalton in passer rating, despite far better situations (Mayfield comes to mind, among others). His rating - if we accept that it was an anomaly, dragged down by his situation - proves nothing.