Which team was a better team 2005 or 2015

[*SHRacerX*]

I don't believe the Bengals would have matched up well with Indy in 2005, but I do believe that 2015 team would be beat (ironically) Manning in the Super Bowl when he was with Denver. I understand it would have been the AFC title game and not the Super Bowl, but I digress. Even as badly as the NFL wanted Manning to win that year, I think the 2015 Bengals team was better. Hell, McCarron almost beat them in Denver, on a prime time game that season. With Dalton, I think they had a really good chance to win it all.