08-10-2020, 11:02 AM
(08-10-2020, 10:43 AM)SHRacerX Wrote: Brady would not be elite where he is today, IMHO. He certainly was, though.
Maybe a better way of framing it is saying top 5 out of all 90 QBs in the NFL. Then your % is close to the top 5%. Top 5 defense being "elite", out of 32 total defenses just runs against my definition of elite.
I would say there is often 1 or maybe 2 elite defenses in the NFL. Rarely are there 5.
Pats, 9ers, Bills, Ravens, all were last season, imo. You could also make a case for the Steelers who had no business winning 8 games without Ben.
But going back to the QB’s I mentioned, even leaving out Brady which of the other 5 aren’t elite in your opinion? I think you’re getting too wrapped up in percentages honestly.