10-21-2015, 11:09 AM
(10-21-2015, 11:03 AM)djs7685 Wrote: Which is exactly my point. Thanks.
If I critiqued Andy's playoff performance in 2012, or if I critiqued Andy's pocket awareness from 2011 - 2013, or if I critiqued his placement on intermediate passes from 2011 - 2014, it doesn't mean that I was "wrong" about all of that stuff just because he improved upon them in 2015.
That was my point. Nothing more, nothing less. A lot of people around here have been throwing out little "told ya so!" messages where they don't necessarily belong. I said before, you can say that Toast deserves a bit of that for his prediction that Andy couldn't/wouldn't improve or whatever, but he doesn't deserve it for any of his objective analysis from 2011 - 2014. Other than joking about his "noodle arm" and stuff, Toast always seemed at least somewhat fair in his analysis, but maybe not his predictions.
Just because you overrated Andy years ago doesn't mean that you were justified in that now that he's actually playing great football. You still overrated the guy in the past, and that doesn't change with his future performances.
Lol. I didn't "overrate" Dalton. I saw him for what he was, whereas people so blinded by 4 playoff losses subjectively wrote him off.
