09-10-2020, 01:55 PM
(09-09-2020, 05:56 PM)TheLeonardLeap Wrote: Based on what?
- - - - - -
WRs about about a wash.
AJ Green >> AJ Green
Jerome Simpson << Tyler Boyd
Andre Caldwell ~ John Ross
RBs has an edge to 2020.
Joe Mixon is coming off 2,300 rushing yards/13 TDs the last two years > Cedric Benson was coming off 2,360 rushing yards/13 TDs the previous two years, but Benson with worse YPC.
TEs is all 2011.
Jermaine Gresham >> CJ Uzomah
OL is MASSIVELY 2011.
Andrew Whitworth >>> Jonah Williams
Nate Livings ~ Michael Johnson
Kyle Cook ~ Trey Hopkins
Bobbie Williams > Xavier Su'a-Filo
Andre Smith >> Bobby Hart
I was referencing skilled players more Boyd is way better than Simpson, the two years he has had on two bad teams was very impressive.. On WR core is considered much deeper on paper.... Mixon is younger and is considered better than Benson as whole at this time.. AJ was rookie, now a veteran.. he is a better player if healthy now but big IF I will agree..
As for the line, I agree 2011 is better but when you look at the players coming into 2011 you would down grade some of them for example Smith had barely played so you could not predict how he would perform... Williams was 34/35 past his prime , he was out of football i believe after 2011.. Hopkins and Cook a wash though I think Hopkins will be better, Cook was done by 2013... Nat Livings so so player.. had one more year in the league... The clear edge was Whit.. hoping Williams performs like we think with his 1st round grade..
In the end I do see the skilled players a clear edge to 2020 and 2011 edge on the line (remember the 2010 line was not that good and outside of a hurt Smith it was pretty much the same line in 2011)