Trask Versus Fields or Wilson?? Or Chase or Parsons?

[Jpoore]

(12-21-2020, 11:05 AM)Clark W Griswold Wrote: I don’t think Fields a lock but I don’t think Trask is going that high either.
Fields looked terrible vs Northwestern and I think you could see some thinking Wilson from BYU is the #2 QB.

I don’t think the Jets will go OT again but I don’t blame their fans for being mad. That win may have cost them a franchise changing QB.

U can’t just dismiss the fact that osu was down 30 players against northwestern.

(12-21-2020, 12:09 PM)ochocincos Wrote: There's no guarantee of that.

Remember the 2018 draft? For most of the offseason prior to that draft, Sam Darnold was the "lock" to be 1st overall.
Mayfield was climbing, but he wasn't even the consensus 2nd QB in that class.

Looking at this year, Trask actually has a higher passing efficiency rating than Fields (186.7 vs 174.6).
Zach Wilson has a higher PER than both of them (195.4).
And as much as it may be an overreaction, Fields did not play well against Northwestern. Given it will be one of the last games he will play in college, it may cause some doubt for some teams. It would help Fields to put together a really good game against Clemson in the CFP semifinal to show that the Northwestern game was an oddity. If he performs poorly against Clemson, it could lead teams to start thinking he's in the same tier as Wilson, Trask, and Lance.

As long as the team isn’t decimated by Covid he’ll play well. He had a bad game against nw, mainly due to him missing 30 players. Wrs were running wro routes no chemistry etc etc.

(12-21-2020, 12:09 PM)Luvnit2 Wrote: I would love a wager, I say no way Fields is a lock as #2 QB in the draft. A lock means, not even worth a discussion. There are 3 QB's that will be in the discussion, Fields, Trask and Wilson with a 4th from a small school possibly as well named Trey Lance. I think 4 of the 5 go in first 16 picks of the draft.

I think GM's look at Haskins out of Ohio State and become very afraid. Haskins was supposed to be a can't miss QB, he looks lost.

Haskins was different. He was coming from Meyers full no need to read a defense mesh/all underneath offensive system. Fields is coming from a multiple read pro style offense.

(12-21-2020, 02:12 PM)KillerGoose Wrote: Fields' playoff game is going to be huge for him. I wouldn't call him a lock as the #2 prospect. His Indiana and Northwestern tape is really pretty bad (Northwestern is horrid). I think he is a better prospect than Haskins was, but he displays some of the same issues. He really panics under pressure and he has this habit to try to do too much when he is danger. There were multiple instances of a defender being on him and he just tries to chuck it down the field and it results in an interception. Trask and Mac Jones have the ability to really, really bump their stock up this bowl season if they come out red hot. Fields is going to need a big game against Clemson imo to remain the #2 QB.

Fields was down 30 players against nw. U can’t ignore that. Struggles under pressure? By what metric Bc he is the best qb in the country under pressure per pff. Fields won’t struggle against Clemson provided he has his players back. He holds it a touch to long that’s the only gripe.