Login

fredtoast · 10-29-2021, 02:20 PM

(10-29-2021, 10:40 AM)Truck_1_0_1_ Wrote: lol THAT'S the type of error I let slide

Yeah, no biggie; again, I can be a grammar Nazi all day if I chose to, but with the modern day of autocorrects and speed, I can understand if things get screwed up (I do it myself).

But the dominant thing... just one of the very few that REALLY irks me

Carry on!

I see a big difference between calling out a grammar mistake because it irks you and calling out grammar in the middle of a heated debate because you have no other argument.

**Shake n Blake** · 10-29-2021, 03:40 PM

(10-29-2021, 06:18 AM)WychesWarrior Wrote: Yeah, for me, it's Greg Cook. Who knows how things would've unfolded had he not gotten injured. Trumpy says their hands would be full of rings, and Bill Walsh said he was the best QB he'd ever seen. That's enough for me.....and I loved Ickey Woods.

He led the AFL in passer rating and yards/attempt that year with a torn rotator cuff.

He deserves respect and a mention, but I wanted to keep the list below 10.

But anywho, that's at least 2 votes for our guy Greg Cook.

**Shake n Blake** · 10-29-2021, 03:43 PM

Poor Eddie Brown is the only guy without a vote, and is the only guy listed who won Rookie of the Year.

***Wyche'sWarrior*** · 10-29-2021, 04:24 PM

(10-29-2021, 03:40 PM)Shake n Blake Wrote: He led the AFL in passer rating and yards/attempt that year with a torn rotator cuff.

He deserves respect and a mention, but I wanted to keep the list below 10.

But anywho, that's at least 2 votes for our guy Greg Cook.

I get it....and that's all we really got, one year. What a shame. From what I've read, and what little I've seen, that guy had it all. There's no way to know for sure, but with Paul Brown and Bill Walsh on the sidelines, and this guy at the helm, it might've been the Bengals building a dynasty instead of Shitsburgh.

fredtoast · 10-29-2021, 04:59 PM

(10-29-2021, 04:24 PM)Wyche Wrote: I get it....and that's all we really got, one year. What a shame. From what I've read, and what little I've seen, that guy had it all. There's no way to know for sure, but with Paul Brown and Bill Walsh on the sidelines, and this guy at the helm, it might've been the Bengals building a dynasty instead of Shitsburgh.

Greg Cook could have changed the entire history of the Bengals franchise. Losing him like that is a tragedy.

But also look at this.

Bengal rookie rushing leaders

Corey Dillon............1129
Jeremy Hill..............1124 (Only rushed for 1774 more yards over 4 seasons. Never had more than 839 yards in a season)
Ickey Woods...........1066 (Only rushed for 459 more yards over 3 seasons)
Paul Robinson.........1023 (Only rushed for 1924 more yards over 5 seasons. Never had more than 622 yards in a season)
Boobie Clark '73...... 988 (Only rushed for 2044 more yards over 7 more seasons. Never had more than 684 yards in a season.)

***bfine32*** · 10-29-2021, 05:18 PM

(10-29-2021, 04:59 PM)fredtoast Wrote: Greg Cook could have changed the entire history of the Bengals franchise. Losing him like that is a tragedy.

But also look at this.

Bengal rookie rushing leaders

Corey Dillon............1129
Jeremy Hill..............1124 (Only rushed for 1774 more yards over 4 seasons. Never had more than 839 yards in a season)
Ickey Woods...........1066 (Only rushed for 459 more yards over 3 seasons)
Paul Robinson.........1023 (Only rushed for 1924 more yards over 5 seasons. Never had more than 622 yards in a season)
Boobie Clark '73...... 988 (Only rushed for 2044 more yards over 7 more seasons. Never had more than 684 yards in a season.)

Those are great but Greg Cook has 2 rookie records that have stood for over 50 years:

Most passing yards per attempt

Most passing yards per completion

When you have 2 records that have withstood 50 years; you had a great rookie season; arguably the best ever by an NFL QB

fredtoast · 10-29-2021, 05:20 PM

(10-29-2021, 05:18 PM)bfine32 Wrote: Those are great but Greg Cook has 2 rookie records that have stood for over 50 years:

Most passing yards per attempt

Most passing yards per completion

When you have 2 records that have withstood 50 years; you had a great rookie season; arguably the best ever by an NFL QB

Agree 100%. Losing a good RB is nothing compared to losing a franchise QB.

**BengalFanInNJ** · 10-29-2021, 08:01 PM

(10-29-2021, 04:59 PM)fredtoast Wrote: Greg Cook could have changed the entire history of the Bengals franchise. Losing him like that is a tragedy.

But also look at this.

Bengal rookie rushing leaders

Corey Dillon............1129
Jeremy Hill..............1124 (Only rushed for 1774 more yards over 4 seasons. Never had more than 839 yards in a season)
Ickey Woods...........1066 (Only rushed for 459 more yards over 3 seasons)
Paul Robinson.........1023 (Only rushed for 1924 more yards over 5 seasons. Never had more than 622 yards in a season)
Boobie Clark '73...... 988 (Only rushed for 2044 more yards over 7 more seasons. Never had more than 684 yards in a season.)

Indeed. Bill Walsh said that he was the best QB he ever coached, including Joe Montana.

***bengalfan74*** · 10-29-2021, 08:50 PM

(10-29-2021, 04:59 PM)fredtoast Wrote: Greg Cook could have changed the entire history of the Bengals franchise. Losing him like that is a tragedy.

But also look at this.

Bengal rookie rushing leaders

Corey Dillon............1129
Jeremy Hill..............1124 (Only rushed for 1774 more yards over 4 seasons. Never had more than 839 yards in a season)
Ickey Woods...........1066 (Only rushed for 459 more yards over 3 seasons)
Paul Robinson.........1023 (Only rushed for 1924 more yards over 5 seasons. Never had more than 622 yards in a season)
Boobie Clark '73...... 988 (Only rushed for 2044 more yards over 7 more seasons. Never had more than 684 yards in a season.)

Perhaps Joe Burrow will ?

***Wyche'sWarrior*** · 10-29-2021, 10:19 PM

(10-29-2021, 04:59 PM)fredtoast Wrote: Greg Cook could have changed the entire history of the Bengals franchise. Losing him like that is a tragedy.

But also look at this.

Bengal rookie rushing leaders

Corey Dillon............1129
Jeremy Hill..............1124 (Only rushed for 1774 more yards over 4 seasons. Never had more than 839 yards in a season)
Ickey Woods...........1066 (Only rushed for 459 more yards over 3 seasons)
Paul Robinson.........1023 (Only rushed for 1924 more yards over 5 seasons. Never had more than 622 yards in a season)
Boobie Clark '73...... 988 (Only rushed for 2044 more yards over 7 more seasons. Never had more than 684 yards in a season.)

Wow.... that's eye opening to say the least. We've had our share of one hit wonders in the backfield.

**Tiger Teeth** · 10-29-2021, 10:29 PM

(10-28-2021, 08:14 PM)michaelsean Wrote: I was between Ickey and Collinsworth. Went with Ickey

I almost went with Collinsworth.

Login
Username:
Password:	Lost Password?
	Remember me

Poll: Best Rookie (before Chase) in team history?
	Corey Dillon
	Cris Collinsworth
	Icky Woods
	AJ Green
	Andy Dalton
	Eddie Brown
	Isaac Curtis
	Carlos Dunlap
	I like to be different (explain)

	[Show Results]

Note: This is a public poll, other users will be able to see what you voted for.