Posts: 27,704
Threads: 344
Reputation:
234740
Joined: Aug 2016
I’ll go with Auden Tate. I spent a lot of time (foolishly) arguing with people like Whatever about how good he was going to be, but I have to eat crow on that one. He’s been massively disappointing, and at this point I don’t think you can really view him as anything more than a 4/5 WR. I really did fall for the hype on him. But a single TD in 28 games played is just horrendous though, and he’s obviously never going to be the red zone weapon so many of us thought he was going to be.
Posts: 1,010
Threads: 5
Reputation:
5447
Joined: Mar 2021
Location: Nyc
Man, so many. Hard to pick.
Offense: Chad. I just thought he was another Warrick. I remember I had a preference for Robert Ferguson instead. His workout #s were through the roof. Chad won me over pretty fast, though. He was a great guy. I'm glad we got him in stripes.
Defense: Big Daddy. I bought all the hype. He was on the cover of SI, wasn't he? I thought he would change my life lol. And in fairness, he did have a reasonable career. He collects an NFL pension today. But he never amounted to that generational player that we were promised. I guess I was wrong less about him than I was about that. Lesson learned.