Which Bengals Could Start on a Top Tier Team? - Printable Version +- Cincinnati Bengals Message Board / Forums - Home of Jungle Noise (http://thebengalsboard.com) +-- Forum: Cincinnati Bengals / NFL (http://thebengalsboard.com/Forum-Cincinnati-Bengals-NFL) +--- Forum: JUNGLE NOISE (http://thebengalsboard.com/Forum-JUNGLE-NOISE) +--- Thread: Which Bengals Could Start on a Top Tier Team? (/Thread-Which-Bengals-Could-Start-on-a-Top-Tier-Team) |
RE: Which Bengals Could Start on a Top Tier Team? - BengalChris - 12-17-2018 (12-17-2018, 11:16 AM)fredtoast Wrote: I didn't forget him, I left him off purposefully. Just like I left off Andy Dalton. RE: Which Bengals Could Start on a Top Tier Team? - bengalfan74 - 12-17-2018 Like others have said a lot depends on which team you're talking about: AJ Green would start for every team. Geno would be a starter on a big bunch of teams. I'm not so sure Carlos would start on every team, he'd get snaps for sure. Mixon would start on a ton of teams. Boyd would start on most teams. Bates and WJII would probably crack several starting rosters. RE: Which Bengals Could Start on a Top Tier Team? - THE PISTONS - 12-17-2018 Malik Jefferson. RE: Which Bengals Could Start on a Top Tier Team? - Wyche'sWarrior - 12-17-2018 (12-17-2018, 02:31 AM)BengalChris Wrote: I'm assuming by Top Tier team you don't mean teams that are hoping to somehow back into the playoffs as a 6th play off seed, but those who are actually "top tier". I'm also assuming you mean all Bengals players including those on IR. I think this would be my list....although I would add Lawson most likely. I think Boyd could start on a couple of them too. RE: Which Bengals Could Start on a Top Tier Team? - Synric - 12-17-2018 Shawn Williams takes a lot of heat but he's actually a solid starting safety. RE: Which Bengals Could Start on a Top Tier Team? - treee - 12-17-2018 Green, Atkins, Mixon, Eifert (if healthy), WJIII, Boyd, Dunlap. I want to put Burfict on the list but there's no telling if he'll ever actually be good again. We have some young guys that look like they might be able to make that list too, but either they're not consistent enough yet warrant it or just aren't good enough yet. RE: Which Bengals Could Start on a Top Tier Team? - 3wt - 12-17-2018 (12-17-2018, 01:04 AM)THE PISTONS Wrote: Eifert? He's played in 43 of 96 possible career regular season games. If he's not injured he starts on every team. Gronk and Olsen are great TEs who have a significant history of injuries. His last injury was not because he was injury prone. Any other TE in that situation would have been out for the year. His receiving skills are out of this world, and his blocking had really improved this year. RE: Which Bengals Could Start on a Top Tier Team? - Nicomo Cosca - 12-17-2018 (12-17-2018, 05:16 PM)3wt Wrote: If he's not injured he starts on every team. Gronk looks pretty close to being done to me. RE: Which Bengals Could Start on a Top Tier Team? - Whatever - 12-17-2018 (12-17-2018, 02:31 AM)BengalChris Wrote: I'm assuming by Top Tier team you don't mean teams that are hoping to somehow back into the playoffs as a 6th play off seed, but those who are actually "top tier". I'm also assuming you mean all Bengals players including those on IR. I agree with most of this. I will say that based purely on merit, Andy would start in Baltimore and probably in Dallas and Chicago. Jared Goff has completely fallen off a cliff, but we have to see if he can right himself. RE: Which Bengals Could Start on a Top Tier Team? - motoarch - 12-17-2018 (12-17-2018, 01:55 AM)TheLeonardLeap Wrote: This list seems pretty good. I think I would actually add Giovani Bernard (I thoroughly expect some to disagree). Bill would love his pass blocking/blitz pickup, pass catching, and ball security, and I have said for years that I think Giovani Bernard on the Saints, Sean Payton, and Brees would be a Pro Bowler. Think Darren Sproles but with more blocking and better running between the tackles (but not as good of a returner). BB would take gio get a 200+ total yardage game out of him then cut him. He loves guys with good skill set he just doesn’t seem to ride them game in and game out. RE: Which Bengals Could Start on a Top Tier Team? - BengalsRocker - 12-17-2018 (12-17-2018, 01:04 AM)THE PISTONS Wrote: Eifert? He's played in 43 of 96 possible career regular season games. Bob says "Hi". RE: Which Bengals Could Start on a Top Tier Team? - BengalsRocker - 12-17-2018 Atkins, Mixon, Dunlap, Green, Erickson, Boyd are sure bets. Gio would be top of the list of rotational players As much as I'm not a fan of them Drek, Williams, and MJ would probably see some play time on other teams. WJ III, Hubbard, Boling, Glenn... perhaps. RE: Which Bengals Could Start on a Top Tier Team? - TheLeonardLeap - 12-17-2018 (12-17-2018, 09:25 PM)BengalsRocker Wrote: Bob says "Hi". Eifert: 43 games played in 6 years, 1x Pro Bowl Sanders: 47 games played in 6 years, 2x Pro Bowls, 2x All-Pros, 1x DPOY Eifert is more fragile than Bob Sanders. RE: Which Bengals Could Start on a Top Tier Team? - BengalsRocker - 12-17-2018 (12-17-2018, 10:39 PM)TheLeonardLeap Wrote: Eifert: 43 games played in 6 years, 1x Pro Bowl RE: Which Bengals Could Start on a Top Tier Team? - SunsetBengal - 12-17-2018 All of y'all are missing the trick to the question. The correct answer is, ALL of them. Because a top tier team has great management and coaching, which would put all of our players in the right position to make a play, at the right time. RE: Which Bengals Could Start on a Top Tier Team? - BengalChris - 12-17-2018 (12-17-2018, 09:08 PM)Whatever Wrote: I agree with most of this. I will say that based purely on merit, Andy would start in Baltimore and probably in Dallas and Chicago. Jared Goff has completely fallen off a cliff, but we have to see if he can right himself. Baltimore is not a top tier team thou. Dalton could start for Buffalo, Miami, Jacksonville, Washington, San Fran and obviously the Bengals and some others I'm not thinking about right now. Chicago is very happy with Trubisky, he went 20 of 28 for 232, 2 TDs and 0 INTs against the Packers on Sunday and they are 10-4 and he has a higher completion percentage and passer rating than Dalton did this year. No one is going to bench Goff, they are 11-3. They've lost to the 11-2 Saints, the 10-4 Bears and last year's SB champions. RE: Which Bengals Could Start on a Top Tier Team? - Go Cards - 12-17-2018 (12-17-2018, 07:46 AM)McC Wrote: I guess this whole thing has gone around the bend for me. I can only take so much of being beaten over the had with how bad we suck, with each thread trying to top all the rest for just how depressing our situation is. Might be a good time for me to step away for awhile. I can only wallow in the muck for so long before it's time to say uncle. Had to take some time away myself. Seems some bask in it. RE: Which Bengals Could Start on a Top Tier Team? - Whatever - 12-17-2018 (12-17-2018, 11:06 PM)BengalChris Wrote: Baltimore is not a top tier team thou. Dalton could start for Buffalo, Miami, Jacksonville, Washington, San Fran and obviously the Bengals and some others I'm not thinking about right now. The question is which Bengals could start for playoff teams, which Baltimore currently is. Trubisky is more of a game manager. He only has 14 more attempts than Dalton despite all the time Dalton has missed. He's not being asked to carry that offense the way Andy was. Not saying he's crap, but if you put them in an objective head to head competition for the starting job, Dalton would likely beat him out. Goff has an abysmal 51.3 QBR the last three weeks, with 1 TD and 7 picks. He is a big reason why the Rams may not even get a 1st round bye now. Now, he should get the chance to right the ship, but a lot of times young QB's come out strong until DC's figure out their weaknesses and tendencies. Then, they fall to earth. RE: Which Bengals Could Start on a Top Tier Team? - BengalChris - 12-18-2018 (12-17-2018, 11:59 PM)Whatever Wrote: The question is which Bengals could start for playoff teams, which Baltimore currently is. The title of the thread is top tier. That's what I went with. AH, yeah, I can see LA and Chicago trying to trade for Dalton tomorrow. Not. RE: Which Bengals Could Start on a Top Tier Team? - THE PISTONS - 12-18-2018 (12-17-2018, 05:16 PM)3wt Wrote: If he's not injured he starts on every team. Once again he's played in 43 of 96 potential games. The 'if he's not injured' portion...can no longer be used on him. He's played in over 8 games exactly TWICE in 6 years. |