+- Cincinnati Bengals Message Board / Forums - Home of Jungle Noise (http://thebengalsboard.com)
+-- Forum: Cincinnati Bengals / NFL (http://thebengalsboard.com/Forum-Cincinnati-Bengals-NFL)
+--- Forum: JUNGLE NOISE (http://thebengalsboard.com/Forum-JUNGLE-NOISE)
+--- Thread: Is Dre K really worth much in trade? (/Thread-Is-Dre-K-really-worth-much-in-trade)
Is Dre K really worth much in trade? - SunsetBengal - 03-03-2020
I don't think so. Especially when you see that a trade market for CBs has just been set, with Jacksonville trading AJ Bouye to Denver, for a 4th round pick.
With Bouye due $13M this year and next, and being a former Pro Bowler, I think it's easy to consider Bouye a bigger name player than Dre Kirkpatrick, whom many around here seem to think of as "great trade bait".
Here's Bouye's contract info.
https://www.spotrac.com/nfl/denver-broncos/aj-bouye-12795/
Not going to waste my time posting link about the trade, it's breaking everywhere, right now.
RE: Is Dre K really worth much in trade? - Au165 - 03-03-2020
Dre could possibly net a 6th but I think we cut him in the end.
RE: Is Dre K really worth much in trade? - SunsetBengal - 03-03-2020
(03-03-2020, 07:55 PM)Au165 Wrote: Dre could possibly net a 6th but I think we cut him in the end.
Cut him, are you thinking that Phillips is ready to step up to be the full time starter? Because I think it would be unwise to cut Dre outright, without at least attempting to get something in return. They would then be creating another roster hole to fill via free agency or the draft, and in the big picture, when healthy he's a solid, experienced corner who might have a career year should the LB position be upgraded appropriately. At least in my opinion.
RE: Is Dre K really worth much in trade? - jason - 03-03-2020
(03-03-2020, 08:16 PM)SunsetBengal Wrote: Cut him, are you thinking that Phillips is ready to step up to be the full time starter? Because I think it would be unwise to cut Dre outright, without at least attempting to get something in return. They would then be creating another roster hole to fill via free agency or the draft, and in the big picture, when healthy he's a solid, experienced corner who might have a career year should the LB position be upgraded appropriately. At least in my opinion.
This... I like Phillips too, but he hasn't played that much. Hell some of us are already sold on the practice squad tackle that played 2 games.
RE: Is Dre K really worth much in trade? - Hammerstripes - 03-03-2020
Given our cap situation, I don't see why we would cut anyone that has been a good contributor. Dre has been solid. I don't think anyone would trade for him and his contract, but I also wouldn't cut him without a good replacement.
RE: Is Dre K really worth much in trade? - SunsetBengal - 03-03-2020
(03-03-2020, 08:19 PM)Hammerstripes Wrote: Given our cap situation, I don't see why we would cut anyone that has been a good contributor. Dre has been solid. I don't think anyone would trade for him and his contract, but I also wouldn't cut him without a good replacement.
I agree, no need to create yet another hole to fill, this year. I say they should let him play it out, and plan to draft his replacement next year. Phillips has looked good enough to hold down the spot, but I don't want him out there as the only option just yet.
RE: Is Dre K really worth much in trade? - QueenCity - 03-03-2020
Cut him and sign a stud. If you can't do that then hang onto him. That simple.
RE: Is Dre K really worth much in trade? - Hammerstripes - 03-03-2020
(03-03-2020, 09:11 PM)QueenCity Wrote: Cut him and sign a stud. If you can't do that then hang onto him. That simple.
LOL..
Have the Bengals ever done that?
RE: Is Dre K really worth much in trade? - Gdale_Bengal - 03-03-2020
Cap hit if we cut the guy? I think if he has little to know cap hit, then they have a another player in FA in mind and cutting him makes sense.
RE: Is Dre K really worth much in trade? - Hammerstripes - 03-03-2020
(03-03-2020, 09:22 PM)Gdale_Bengal Wrote: Cap hit if we cut the guy? I think if he has little to know cap hit, then they have a another player in FA in mind and cutting him makes sense.
Any player of his caliber will cost us more. I'd roll with him and Phillips one more year. If Phillips beats him out, then he's done.
RE: Is Dre K really worth much in trade? - Au165 - 03-03-2020
(03-03-2020, 08:16 PM)SunsetBengal Wrote: Cut him, are you thinking that Phillips is ready to step up to be the full time starter? Because I think it would be unwise to cut Dre outright, without at least attempting to get something in return. They would then be creating another roster hole to fill via free agency or the draft, and in the big picture, when healthy he's a solid, experienced corner who might have a career year should the LB position be upgraded appropriately. At least in my opinion.
I believe we will sign a relatively high priced FA corner(or trade for one) as wild as that sounds. Historically corner is one of those places we have always been willing to pay top dollar, usually too our own guys but I wonder if that was as much a Marvin preference than anything.
RE: Is Dre K really worth much in trade? - SunsetBengal - 03-03-2020
(03-03-2020, 09:27 PM)Au165 Wrote: I believe we will sign a relatively high priced FA corner(or trade for one) as wild as that sounds. Historically corner is one of those places we have always been willing to pay top dollar, usually too our own guys but I wonder if that was as much a Marvin preference than anything.
Yeah, that's part of where mine and the team's philosophy on value of defensive personnel differs. I think that you get more mileage out of having great Safeties than you do with great Corners.
RE: Is Dre K really worth much in trade? - Nate (formerly eliminate08) - 03-03-2020
(03-03-2020, 09:27 PM)Au165 Wrote: I believe we will sign a relatively high priced FA corner(or trade for one) as wild as that sounds. Historically corner is one of those places we have always been willing to pay top dollar, usually too our own guys but I wonder if that was as much a Marvin preference than anything.
Who do you think would be on our radar? Slay is out of the question.
I am on the bubble with cutting Kirkpatrick still. I understand Sunset, Jason and Hammerstripes thoughts here.
Might want to wait for next year to cut Dre, I just don't see some solid Corner here.
Dre is bad at tackling and is not a good cover Corner. He tries hard, I will give him this and he is better than Webb.
RE: Is Dre K really worth much in trade? - Nate (formerly eliminate08) - 03-03-2020
(03-03-2020, 09:41 PM)SunsetBengal Wrote: Yeah, that's part of where mine and the team's philosophy on value of defensive personnel differs. I think that you get more mileage out of having great Safeties than you do with great Corners.
Karl Joseph would be my guy if we want a Safety in FA.
RE: Is Dre K really worth much in trade? - Synric - 03-03-2020
Darius Phillips deserves a chance to start and he looks best on the outside.
RE: Is Dre K really worth much in trade? - Socal Bengals fan - 03-03-2020
Dre n Webb should be cut. Addition by subtraction
RE: Is Dre K really worth much in trade? - sandwedge - 03-03-2020
(03-03-2020, 08:18 PM)jason Wrote: This... I like Phillips too, but he hasn't played that much. Hell some of us are already sold on the practice squad tackle that played 2 games.
I'm with you and Sunset on this. A couple of years ago, I remember a CB on the roster that played lights out in spot duty, we all want him to start, well he did, 1 game and shit the bed. Can't remember the name though?
RE: Is Dre K really worth much in trade? - sandwedge - 03-03-2020
(03-03-2020, 09:57 PM)Socal Bengals fan Wrote: Dre n Webb should be cut. Addition by subtraction
I have a feeling both guys will be around training camp.
RE: Is Dre K really worth much in trade? - Nate (formerly eliminate08) - 03-03-2020
(03-03-2020, 09:51 PM)Synric Wrote: Darius Phillips deserves a chance to start and he looks best on the outside.
He does in my limited vision, he is a ballhawk and can take it to the house on any play as well.
Seems like a gamechanger to me. I can handle my Corners getting beat a bit and then making a big play.
I just cannot handle my Corners getting beat over and over again and not making a play while just trying hard and making lots of
dough in doing such. Dre just shouldn't make so much money because of this and him being a 1st round pick. He clearly is not a
good 1st round pick, he just isn't a bad Cornerback. I don't consider Kirkpatrick solid if he is a terrible tackler, cannot hold onto the
ball and has trouble covering often.
RE: Is Dre K really worth much in trade? - Passepartout - 03-03-2020
Yeah as really D.P. could be a starter right away.