Cincinnati Bengals Message Board / Forums - Home of Jungle Noise
should we have kept iraqi oil - Printable Version

+- Cincinnati Bengals Message Board / Forums - Home of Jungle Noise (http://thebengalsboard.com)
+-- Forum: Off Topic Forums (http://thebengalsboard.com/Forum-Off-Topic-Forums)
+--- Forum: Politics & Religion 2.0 (http://thebengalsboard.com/Forum-Politics-Religion-2-0)
+---- Forum: P & R Archive (http://thebengalsboard.com/Forum-P-R-Archive)
+---- Thread: should we have kept iraqi oil (/Thread-should-we-have-kept-iraqi-oil)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


should we have kept iraqi oil - Griever - 01-26-2017

http://www.cnn.com/2017/01/26/politics/trump-oil-isis-iraq/index.html

i think he needs a mental health evaluation


RE: should we have kept iraqi oil - jason - 01-26-2017

I guess we should have. When you throw together a "coalition of the willing", and preemptively invade a country, you may as well go all out.


RE: should we have kept iraqi oil - Mike M (the other one) - 01-26-2017

We should not have "kept" it per say, but I see nothing wrong with them paying us back via a % of each barrel sold to pay us back for the war, but the time for that has come and gone.


RE: should we have kept iraqi oil - Griever - 01-26-2017

(01-26-2017, 02:12 PM)Mike M (the other one) Wrote: We should not have "kept" it per say, but I see nothing wrong with them paying us back via a % of each barrel sold to pay us back for the war, but the time for that has come and gone.

maybe we'll go back in and get it


RE: should we have kept iraqi oil - CageTheBengal - 01-26-2017

Last night when Muir told him that was a war crime Trump just goes...

"Can you believe that?"

and then repeats it 3 more times like his brain is malfunctioning.


RE: should we have kept iraqi oil - Griever - 01-26-2017

(01-26-2017, 02:31 PM)CageTheBengal Wrote: Last night when Muir told him that was a war crime Trump just goes...

"Can you believe that?"

and then repeats it 3 more times like his brain is malfunctioning.

trump is a brain dead chimp


RE: should we have kept iraqi oil - CageTheBengal - 01-26-2017

(01-26-2017, 02:00 PM)Griever Wrote: http://www.cnn.com/2017/01/26/politics/trump-oil-isis-iraq/index.html

i think he needs a mental health evaluation

Well if it's anything like his medical evaluation during the campaign it will go something like this.


"As Trump's mental physician I declare that Trump is in perfect mental health. In fact he is the most mentally fit president ever to live. Mr.Trump showed me his telekinesis abilities and bent a spoon with his mind. I was astonished to find out he has the hugest and most pristine brain in the world. It's truly bigly."


RE: should we have kept iraqi oil - oncemoreuntothejimbreech - 01-26-2017

(01-26-2017, 02:12 PM)Mike M (the other one) Wrote: We should not have "kept" it per say, but I see nothing wrong with them paying us back via a % of each barrel sold to pay us back for the war, but the time for that has come and gone.

We invaded Iraq for our national security issues. Allegedly. Why would the Iraqi government feel compelled to pay us for an invasion we conducted for our own benefit?


RE: should we have kept iraqi oil - Griever - 01-26-2017

(01-26-2017, 03:32 PM)oncemoreuntothejimbreech Wrote: We invaded Iraq for our national security issues. Allegedly. Why would the Iraqi government feel compelled to pay us for an invasion we conducted for our own benefit?

as a thank you for the hugely awesome job we did, better than everyone else ever did

we have the best democracies


RE: should we have kept iraqi oil - Benton - 01-26-2017

(01-26-2017, 02:12 PM)Mike M (the other one) Wrote: We should not have "kept" it per say, but I see nothing wrong with them paying us back via a % of each barrel sold to pay us back for the war, but the time for that has come and gone.

Paying us back for....? Destroying their economy?

If I go into your house uninvited, light it on fire and then send you a bill for the matches, are you going to pay it?


RE: should we have kept iraqi oil - bfine32 - 01-26-2017

Trump sure is greedy.


RE: should we have kept iraqi oil - bfine32 - 01-26-2017

(01-26-2017, 03:52 PM)Benton Wrote: Paying us back for....?

Saddam Hussein was hanged for ordering the deaths of 148 Shiite men and boys in the village of Dujail after an assassination attempt there in 1982. But by the standards of his brutal rule, the Dujail killings were a relatively minor crime.


The exact number of deaths attributable to Saddam Hussein may never be known, but estimates range as high as half a million. There is evidence of more than 250 mass graves dating to his rule.

Following is a list of other crimes Saddam is accused of. The most notorious is his genocidal campaign against the Kurds in the north. The trial for those murders, and for others, will now continue with the remaining defendants.


1974 -- Dawa Killings

Five leaders of the Shiite Islamic Dawa Party were sentenced to death and killed as Saddam consolidated his power. In 2004, those murders were among many charges announced against Saddam. The U.S. State Department estimates thousands of Saddam's political rivals were killed.


1980 -- Fayli Deportations and Killings

Thousands of Kurds of the Fayli sect were persecuted. Some were expelled to Iran, others killed. Saddam thought of them as Iranian, and therefore as enemies. Fayli women were often imprisoned or put into camps.


1983 -- Barzani Abductions

After the Iraqi-based Kurdistan Democratic Party allied with Iran during the Iran-Iraq War, Saddam sought to punish the clan and its leader, Massoud Barzani. More than 5,000 males, some as young as 10, disappeared. Decades later the remains of 512 Barzani men were discovered in a mass grave. They were reinterred in 2005. A letter that shows Saddam's direct involvement in the crimes was discovered in Baghdad.


1988 -- Al-Anfal Campaign

From February to September 1988, Saddam conducted what has been called a genocidal campaign against the Kurdish population. Gen. Ali Hassan al-Majid, or "Chemical Ali," Saddam's cousin, carried out the Al-Anfal operation using chemical weapons. Human Rights Watch estimates between 50,000 and 100,000 died. Kurdish officials and some international human rights groups put the number killed as high as 182,000. Saddam was on trial for the Anfal campaign at the time of his execution. Six defendants remain in the Al-Anfal case, including "Chemical Ali," who is facing charges of genocide.


1988 -- Halabja Gassing

During the Anfal campaign, "Chemical Ali" ordered an attack against civilians in the town of Halabja. Iraqi forces dropped bombs containing mustard and nerve gases. An estimated 5,000 men, women and children died in a single day. Many more died from long-term medical problems, and birth defects are still common in the area.


1990s -- Marsh Arabs Devastated

Saddam attacked the Shiite "Marsh Arabs" by destroying their land. Once a significant wetland, the marshes in southern Iraq were devastated by a government drainage plan that left behind a wasteland. In 1991, 250,000 Marsh Arabs lived in the region. Now 90 percent of the area is in ruins and only an estimated 20,000 people remain. Tens of thousands live in refugee camps in Iran. Efforts are now underway to restore the marshes. Human Rights Watch calls the campaign against the Marsh Arabs a crime against humanity and other rights activists call it genocide. There are claims chemical weapons also were used.


1990 -- Invasion of Kuwait

In August of 1990, Saddam ordered the Iraqi military, the fourth largest military in the world at the time, to invade Kuwait, leading to the 1991 Gulf War. Iraqi soldiers are accused of torturing and executing hundreds of Kuwaitis, as well as taking hostages and looting. More than 700 oil wells were set on fire and pipelines opened, spilling oil into the Gulf.


1991 -- Kurdish and Shiite Rebellions

After heeding President George H.W. Bush's call to rebel against Saddam, Shiites and Kurds were crushed by immense Iraqi military force. Saddam turned his military against the people as part of his widespread crackdown after the war. The rebels thought they would have the backing of the U.S. military. Thousands have been discovered in mass graves.


1999 -- Al-Sadr Assassination

Ayatollah Muhammed al-Sadr, father of prominent Shiite cleric Muqtada al-Sadr, and two of his sons were assassinated in 1999. Al-Sadr was a well-liked Shiite leader, and his death spawned Shiite uprisings in Baghdad. As he had previously, Saddam cracked down on the rebellion and hundreds were killed.

In a statement responding to the execution, Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri Al-Maliki said, "Let the families of Iraqi martyrs killed in mass graves, Anfal, Halabja or those executed in the cells of the dead regime be happy. The mothers, orphans and widows should celebrate the death of the buried dictator."


RE: should we have kept iraqi oil - oncemoreuntothejimbreech - 01-26-2017

(01-26-2017, 03:58 PM)bfine32 Wrote: Saddam Hussein was hanged for ordering the deaths of 148 Shiite men and boys in the village of Dujail after an assassination attempt there in 1982. But by the standards of his brutal rule, the Dujail killings were a relatively minor crime.


The exact number of deaths attributable to Saddam Hussein may never be known, but estimates range as high as half a million. There is evidence of more than 250 mass graves dating to his rule.

Following is a list of other crimes Saddam is accused of. The most notorious is his genocidal campaign against the Kurds in the north. The trial for those murders, and for others, will now continue with the remaining defendants.


1974 -- Dawa Killings

Five leaders of the Shiite Islamic Dawa Party were sentenced to death and killed as Saddam consolidated his power. In 2004, those murders were among many charges announced against Saddam. The U.S. State Department estimates thousands of Saddam's political rivals were killed.


1980 -- Fayli Deportations and Killings

Thousands of Kurds of the Fayli sect were persecuted. Some were expelled to Iran, others killed. Saddam thought of them as Iranian, and therefore as enemies. Fayli women were often imprisoned or put into camps.


1983 -- Barzani Abductions

After the Iraqi-based Kurdistan Democratic Party allied with Iran during the Iran-Iraq War, Saddam sought to punish the clan and its leader, Massoud Barzani. More than 5,000 males, some as young as 10, disappeared. Decades later the remains of 512 Barzani men were discovered in a mass grave. They were reinterred in 2005. A letter that shows Saddam's direct involvement in the crimes was discovered in Baghdad.


1988 -- Al-Anfal Campaign

From February to September 1988, Saddam conducted what has been called a genocidal campaign against the Kurdish population. Gen. Ali Hassan al-Majid, or "Chemical Ali," Saddam's cousin, carried out the Al-Anfal operation using chemical weapons. Human Rights Watch estimates between 50,000 and 100,000 died. Kurdish officials and some international human rights groups put the number killed as high as 182,000. Saddam was on trial for the Anfal campaign at the time of his execution. Six defendants remain in the Al-Anfal case, including "Chemical Ali," who is facing charges of genocide.


1988 -- Halabja Gassing

During the Anfal campaign, "Chemical Ali" ordered an attack against civilians in the town of Halabja. Iraqi forces dropped bombs containing mustard and nerve gases. An estimated 5,000 men, women and children died in a single day. Many more died from long-term medical problems, and birth defects are still common in the area.


1990s -- Marsh Arabs Devastated

Saddam attacked the Shiite "Marsh Arabs" by destroying their land. Once a significant wetland, the marshes in southern Iraq were devastated by a government drainage plan that left behind a wasteland. In 1991, 250,000 Marsh Arabs lived in the region. Now 90 percent of the area is in ruins and only an estimated 20,000 people remain. Tens of thousands live in refugee camps in Iran. Efforts are now underway to restore the marshes. Human Rights Watch calls the campaign against the Marsh Arabs a crime against humanity and other rights activists call it genocide. There are claims chemical weapons also were used.


1990 -- Invasion of Kuwait

In August of 1990, Saddam ordered the Iraqi military, the fourth largest military in the world at the time, to invade Kuwait, leading to the 1991 Gulf War. Iraqi soldiers are accused of torturing and executing hundreds of Kuwaitis, as well as taking hostages and looting. More than 700 oil wells were set on fire and pipelines opened, spilling oil into the Gulf.


1991 -- Kurdish and Shiite Rebellions

After heeding President George H.W. Bush's call to rebel against Saddam, Shiites and Kurds were crushed by immense Iraqi military force. Saddam turned his military against the people as part of his widespread crackdown after the war. The rebels thought they would have the backing of the U.S. military. Thousands have been discovered in mass graves.


1999 -- Al-Sadr Assassination

Ayatollah Muhammed al-Sadr, father of prominent Shiite cleric Muqtada al-Sadr, and two of his sons were assassinated in 1999. Al-Sadr was a well-liked Shiite leader, and his death spawned Shiite uprisings in Baghdad. As he had previously, Saddam cracked down on the rebellion and hundreds were killed.

In a statement responding to the execution, Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri Al-Maliki said, "Let the families of Iraqi martyrs killed in mass graves, Anfal, Halabja or those executed in the cells of the dead regime be happy. The mothers, orphans and widows should celebrate the death of the buried dictator."

Did Colin Powell brief the UN on any of these as a reason to invade Iraq?


RE: should we have kept iraqi oil - bfine32 - 01-26-2017

(01-26-2017, 06:20 PM)oncemoreuntothejimbreech Wrote: Did Colin Powell brief the UN on any of these as a reason to invade Iraq?

I'm not sure; however, that has nothing to do with the fact that he committed those and countless other atrocities and we removed him from power in an effort to help the citizens of Iraq; as opposed to the snarky arm-chair reason provided.


RE: should we have kept iraqi oil - GMDino - 01-26-2017

(01-26-2017, 07:01 PM)bfine32 Wrote: I'm not sure; however, that has nothing to do with the fact that he committed those and countless other atrocities and we removed him from power in an effort to help the citizens of Iraq; as opposed to the snarky arm-chair reason provided.

Yeah, but those reasons were not why we went into Iraq.  

WMD's.  Sure.

To defend the UN resolution.  Um...

9/11.  Uh...


RE: should we have kept iraqi oil - Benton - 01-26-2017

(01-26-2017, 03:58 PM)bfine32 Wrote: Saddam Hussein was hanged for ordering the deaths of 148 Shiite men and boys in the village of Dujail after an assassination attempt there in 1982. But by the standards of his brutal rule, the Dujail killings were a relatively minor crime.


The exact number of deaths attributable to Saddam Hussein may never be known, but estimates range as high as half a million. There is evidence of more than 250 mass graves dating to his rule.

Following is a list of other crimes Saddam is accused of. The most notorious is his genocidal campaign against the Kurds in the north. The trial for those murders, and for others, will now continue with the remaining defendants.


1974 -- Dawa Killings

Five leaders of the Shiite Islamic Dawa Party were sentenced to death and killed as Saddam consolidated his power. In 2004, those murders were among many charges announced against Saddam. The U.S. State Department estimates thousands of Saddam's political rivals were killed.


1980 -- Fayli Deportations and Killings

Thousands of Kurds of the Fayli sect were persecuted. Some were expelled to Iran, others killed. Saddam thought of them as Iranian, and therefore as enemies. Fayli women were often imprisoned or put into camps.


1983 -- Barzani Abductions

After the Iraqi-based Kurdistan Democratic Party allied with Iran during the Iran-Iraq War, Saddam sought to punish the clan and its leader, Massoud Barzani. More than 5,000 males, some as young as 10, disappeared. Decades later the remains of 512 Barzani men were discovered in a mass grave. They were reinterred in 2005. A letter that shows Saddam's direct involvement in the crimes was discovered in Baghdad.


1988 -- Al-Anfal Campaign

From February to September 1988, Saddam conducted what has been called a genocidal campaign against the Kurdish population. Gen. Ali Hassan al-Majid, or "Chemical Ali," Saddam's cousin, carried out the Al-Anfal operation using chemical weapons. Human Rights Watch estimates between 50,000 and 100,000 died. Kurdish officials and some international human rights groups put the number killed as high as 182,000. Saddam was on trial for the Anfal campaign at the time of his execution. Six defendants remain in the Al-Anfal case, including "Chemical Ali," who is facing charges of genocide.


1988 -- Halabja Gassing

During the Anfal campaign, "Chemical Ali" ordered an attack against civilians in the town of Halabja. Iraqi forces dropped bombs containing mustard and nerve gases. An estimated 5,000 men, women and children died in a single day. Many more died from long-term medical problems, and birth defects are still common in the area.


1990s -- Marsh Arabs Devastated

Saddam attacked the Shiite "Marsh Arabs" by destroying their land. Once a significant wetland, the marshes in southern Iraq were devastated by a government drainage plan that left behind a wasteland. In 1991, 250,000 Marsh Arabs lived in the region. Now 90 percent of the area is in ruins and only an estimated 20,000 people remain. Tens of thousands live in refugee camps in Iran. Efforts are now underway to restore the marshes. Human Rights Watch calls the campaign against the Marsh Arabs a crime against humanity and other rights activists call it genocide. There are claims chemical weapons also were used.


1990 -- Invasion of Kuwait

In August of 1990, Saddam ordered the Iraqi military, the fourth largest military in the world at the time, to invade Kuwait, leading to the 1991 Gulf War. Iraqi soldiers are accused of torturing and executing hundreds of Kuwaitis, as well as taking hostages and looting. More than 700 oil wells were set on fire and pipelines opened, spilling oil into the Gulf.


1991 -- Kurdish and Shiite Rebellions

After heeding President George H.W. Bush's call to rebel against Saddam, Shiites and Kurds were crushed by immense Iraqi military force. Saddam turned his military against the people as part of his widespread crackdown after the war. The rebels thought they would have the backing of the U.S. military. Thousands have been discovered in mass graves.


1999 -- Al-Sadr Assassination

Ayatollah Muhammed al-Sadr, father of prominent Shiite cleric Muqtada al-Sadr, and two of his sons were assassinated in 1999. Al-Sadr was a well-liked Shiite leader, and his death spawned Shiite uprisings in Baghdad. As he had previously, Saddam cracked down on the rebellion and hundreds were killed.

In a statement responding to the execution, Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri Al-Maliki said, "Let the families of Iraqi martyrs killed in mass graves, Anfal, Halabja or those executed in the cells of the dead regime be happy. The mothers, orphans and widows should celebrate the death of the buried dictator."


I get some in the U.S. were terrified of an army that — at its height — we defeated in a few hours with a fraction of our resources. But going over your list, how many Americans were actually threatened by the guy hiding in his oil well? What justified us dismantling the government, and thereby increasing extremism in the region? Who in Iraq issued the invitation of "come, dispose us of our despot!"

And why did we stop? If that's suddenly our job — ridding the world of crappy leaders — why didn't we invade Russia? Cuba? North Korea? And bill them, of course.


RE: should we have kept iraqi oil - NATI BENGALS - 01-26-2017

Trump is genius. We could turn in to like a mercenary country.

Bad guys slaughtering your people committing horrible atrocities? Well well well. We have a solution for you. If you can afford it we will help you.

As a strong proud Christian nation. Doesn't it say something in the bible about protecting and helping the poor and needy if they can pay for it?


RE: should we have kept iraqi oil - Benton - 01-26-2017

(01-26-2017, 07:43 PM)NATI BENGALS Wrote: Trump is genius. We could turn in to like a mercenary country.

Bad guys slaughtering your people committing horrible atrocities? Well well well. We have a solution for you. If you can afford it we will help you.

As a strong proud Christian nation. Doesn't it say something in the bible about protecting and helping the poor and needy if they can pay for it?

[Image: 400?cb=20140228191543http:]

I pity the foo' who messes with Lady Liberty!


RE: should we have kept iraqi oil - CKwi88 - 01-26-2017

Well, it wouldn't be the first war crime that our current president would approve of.


RE: should we have kept iraqi oil - bfine32 - 01-26-2017

(01-26-2017, 07:27 PM)Benton Wrote: I get some in the U.S. were terrified of an army that — at its height — we defeated in a few hours with a fraction of our resources. But going over your list, how many Americans were actually threatened by the guy hiding in his oil well? What justified us dismantling the government, and thereby increasing extremism in the region? Who in Iraq issued the invitation of "come, dispose us of our despot!"

And why did we stop? If that's suddenly our job — ridding the world of crappy leaders — why didn't we invade Russia? Cuba? North Korea? And bill them, of course.

Dang you ask a lot of questions when one gets answered but I will try:

I don't know the numbers of Americans threatened by Saddam Hussan, but I'll put it at a few

Their leader committing crimes against humanity, we are not responsible for the increased extremism

Saddam Hussan invited us with his repeated crimes; I'm not sure they actually have an invitation committee

I'm not sure if you are talking about Desert Storm or Iraqi Freedom when asking why did we stop; you're kind of inter-mingling them here

We don't invade all countries because sanctions are perhaps more effective on poorer countries


I think I got them all.