Hobson on Sirius

[Okeana]

(04-05-2016, 09:45 PM)fredtoast Wrote: Okay.  Let me try again just using small words and simple sentences.

Jeremy Hill had a great rookie season but slumped his second year.

Giovani Bernard had a great rookie season but slumped his second year.

You claim that Hill is overrated because of his good rookie season, but you never claimed that Gio was overrated because of his good rookie season.

Since you took opposite positions under the same fact pattern you are not being logically consistent.

Oh i see now.  Life is much easier when you speak clearly and don't speak half way out of your ass because you think you're clever.

Hill has consistently fumbled in both seasons.  His success in the first year is directly related to our team going run first because of injuries and our O-Line carrying him.  

Gio has preformed well when he hasn't been injured.  I never rated Gio off a singular season that's the failed logic of Hill supporters not a realist like myself.

I evaluated both players equally under the same guidelines.  Again what exactly does this have to do with Zeke and are you simply saying that given the chance you would not draft a top 10 running back because you feel our team is better served by sticking with Jeremy Hill?  That is kinda the whole reason for the discussion.