Rank our Backup QB

[wolfkaosaun]

(05-25-2016, 02:52 PM)Savagehenry54 Wrote: Schaub?  Man, no.  Has he accomplished more?  More proven?  Yea, sure.

But with Aj already here, in this system and considering age and apparent career trajectory of each player....it's nuts to suggest the Bengals would be better served to install Schaub over mccaron as back up.

Fitzpatrick, okay, but Fitz is a starter in this league.  Chad henne and a lot of the other names I've seen thrown around in this thread are insane.  Aj did well for himself last year.  We finally got a decent backup and folks are still hatin lol

I can agree on that. Schaub has some decent parts to his game, which is similar to McCarron. But McCarron is younger and cheaper.

However, with that said, neither one is really "above and beyond" the other.

I don't see why bringing up other names in "Rank our backup QB" is such a bad thing. That's what this thread is about. Discussing where the backup ranks. There's backup QBs that are better than McCarron.

And what do you mean "finally have a decent backup QB"? Jason Campbell was a decent backup QB. Bruce Gradkowski was a decent backup QB. Ryan Fitzpatrick was obviously a decent backup QB.

People had an odd love for Dan LeFevour.

We've had decent backup QBs.