Rank our Backup QB

[Brownshoe]

(05-28-2016, 07:02 PM)bengal kitten uk Wrote: You're blinded by your hate.

I'm not saying they're similar.

What I'm saying is that QBs get better over time and deciding after 5 games that he's never going to be good enough is a bit silly.  We had 4 years of people saying Dalton was only fit to be a backup, and yet here we are approaching year 6 and that conversation has been put to bed.  Why do you think AJM won't similarly continue to improve with experience?

I've heard experts say that if you get .500 out of your backup you'll be in good shape when the starter returns and AJM is definitely good enough to do that on this team.  Whether he'd be able to do that on the Browns is a different story - but when your starter can't even manage .500 nobody cares who the backup is.

I'm not blinded by anything. I'm sorry that I'm rational about our players. McCarron hasn't shown that he could do anything except take a team with talent in almost every position around him and beat teams that only could win 5 games in a year. Dalton took a team everyone thought was going to win 2 games and took them to the playoffs. You're the blind one if you think those two things are comparable.