Andy top 5 qb of all time?

[*Nately120*]

(07-10-2016, 06:43 PM)wolfkaosaun Wrote: I wasn't talking about all time. Nately asked when was Dalton considered a top 5 QB in a season. That's what I was responding to.

Dalton a top 5 QB of all time? He's going to have to do some CRAZY AMAZING things for that to happen. And I hope it does.

I'm aware you were directly addressing my question, but I tied it back to the original theme of the thread, my bad!  This reminds me of last off-season's debate on ranking the Bengals' QBs where I pointed out that Anderson, Esiason, and Palmer all had higher peaks and rankings compared to the field of QBs at the time than Dalton did.  Dalton was on his way to that in 2015, but an injury threw it out of whack. I was just saying that Dalton is going to have to start/keep showing he's top 5 (for a whole season) against the guys playing now before we can rank him in the top 5 of every QB to ever step on the field.

Anywho, this thread seems to be about net career yards SO I guess Dalton COULD end up top 5 of all time in that category.