A few questions to ponder

[fredtoast]

(07-08-2015, 07:24 AM)djs7685 Wrote: Honestly, I'm just done with this because you just pick certain threads and HAVE to be the contrarian. You refuse to admit when you're wrong and called out for this stuff (as I proved by the huge leap in rating when the Saints game is taken out compared to other games being taken out). He played well for 5 games, the wheels fell off, he looked good in a game or two after that, but generally he looked like crap for the rest of the year. Fredtoast saying otherwise doesn't change it, all of us with functioning eyes saw it without needing to manipulate all of the stats in the world to create an imaginary point.

Sorry it has offended you so much that I have disagreed with you.  It has nothing with me "just being a contrarian". It has to do with you being wrong about Dalton "looking like crap" after the first five games of the year.

And I find it a little funny when you claim my entire argument is just "because Fredtoast says so" when I have gone to the trouble to post solid facts to back up my position.  I agree he looked better at the beginning of the season, but your claim that he "looked like crap for the rest of the year" just is not true."

Dalton had 4 good games in his first 5.  After that he only had 5 good games in his last 11.  So he certainly became more inconsistent as the season progressed.  But 5 good games is a lot more than "a couple" and he actually had his two best games in the second half of the season.